Movie Review: 'New Year's Eve'—Don't Toast With This Cocktail

Garry Marshall-directed film delivers cinematic hangover.

First off, don't we all have enough of a challenge making New Year's Eve a holiday we actually enjoy? Well-meaning director Garry Marshall's latest holiday offering, while clearly attempting to get us into the spirit of hope and optimism, falls so short it feels like a cinematic hangover without the delightful drunk the night before.  

Watching "New Year's Eve" is a bit like watching an old episode of "Love Boat," only on land, with cell phones, and with a much bigger budget. A budget big enough to attract actors and actresses who should know better and aim higher. There are Oscar winners in this movie, for pity's sake!  

It's most disappointing for those expecting to see anything akin to "Love Actually." That movie is the perennial high bar Marshall clearly attempts to reach, first with 2010's "Valentine's Day," and less failingly (by a small margin) with "New Year's Eve," partly because with "VD" we've been numbed into lowered expectations, and because they make New York look so darn holiday festive in this.  

Those looking for a mostly feel-good holiday trifle won't leave entirely deflated, but might do better to DVR one of the dozens of Hallmark seasonal offerings and toast to saving the cost of admission.   

Let me be clear here. I have actually made Siren Spouse sit through a number of cheesy made-for-TV holiday movies, so I walked into this movie with an open chick flick-loving girlie mind, having seen and not having thoroughly hated "Valentine's Day." I still wanted to turn back the clock to get my valuable holiday viewing time back.  

What we have is a mishmash of mini-stories and subplots, made into uber-schmaltz by trying to take about 10 stories that have already been made far better in far less-cliched ways as full feature-length films, then shortening, simplifying, and whitewashing them so as to reduce each one to forgettable, incoherent, and plastic messes.

Jon Bon Jovi and Katherine Heigl are a rock star and his jilted lover, a catering chef who spends the evening of her biggest event outside the kitchen. I don't think so.

Michelle Pfeiffer and Zac Efron are a lonely woman and the fast-talking hottie smart aleck she hires to help her cross items off her bucket list, a plot line which could have become a more interesting "Harold and Maude" sort of story, but sadly went nowhere. 

Sarah Jessica Parker and Abigail Breslin play a mother chasing her rule-breaking daughter into the festivity fray. Among many other plots are Ashton Kutcher and Lea Michele as strangers trapped in an elevator, which is oft-listed as the #1 subject to avoid as a fiction writer.

I hope the screenwriter (and niece of "I Dream of Jeannie's" Barbara Eden, Katherine Fugate), was trapped in an elevator and threatened by the producers into these meandering plot messes.  It would be her only excuse. The actors are so much better than the script, they almost made up for it. Almost.

On the plus side, if you approach the movie with a forgiving holiday spirit, and you are a huge fan of any two actors in "New Year's Eve," you can bask in the obvious enjoyment the clearly unfazed cast had play-acting with each other, and in work that makes an inexcusably bad script tolerable. New York looks beautiful, and viewers can let themselves get carried into the stories through the many lovely images of the city dressed in it's holiday best.  

Bear in mind, however, when you go expecting to see and enjoy your favorite star, no one actor has much screen time. What does get lots of screen time, is the shameless parade of product placements. This makes the viewers repeatedly wonder if director Marshall's warm-hearted intent to spread holiday love was split with his intent to spread advertising. Cynicism has no place in this movie. Witness the veritable sea of blue Nivea lotion party hats in Times Square, and the loving visual caress of a billboard pimping the Sherlock Holmes sequel, also being released by Warner Brothers. 

If the movie survives more than a week in theaters, that particular placement is likely to backfire into a stampede of viewers leaving one screening mid-film for the one next door.  

There are a few nuts blind squirrel director Marshall finds in the protracted 118 minutes, due mostly to the quality of actors present. Robert DeNiro finds a way to show his talents even in some truly bad movies (sadly, a list that continues to increase), and does so as a regretful cancer patient looking back on his life.  

Kutcher is believable as he builds a crush on fellow trappie Michelle, and he'll have a hefty portion of gals in the audience wishing they'd been trapped with him. On the other hand, those are two of the weakest plots in the movie. With them, and a few other scenes, we forget how bad the film as a whole is, but we never forget enough not to wait for the DVD.

I'm assuming Marshall has a long list of projects lined up for the near future.  We can all look forward to "Mother's Day," "Memorial Day," then on to "Presidents' Day" and "Secretary's Day."  I say, just say no now to another movie that believes it can spray celebrity all over a shallow sub-par script and believe they can hand it to us and we'll toast and drink it up like a kid-concocted schlock cocktail.  

New Year's is the time we all celebrate the fact that we've lived long enough to know better. We learned to ask for our drinks, our holidays, and our movies served to us with a little more cohesion, depth, and even panache. None of these actors will stop working after this movie.

Go if you must.  It won't kill you.  But as this New Year's approaches, let's all decide we can ask for more. Let's ask for panache and get it.  

Here are a few feel-good optimistic movies with star ensemble casts, one that even has some actors from this movie, and three that capture the essence of New York City beautifully.  

I recommend:  

  • "Hairspray": John Travolta, Michelle Pfeiffer, James Marsden, Zac Efron, and a ton more greats, having a blast in this funky sweet musical confection with depth.
  • "On the Town (1949): Here's a movie that shows having fun in New York, with Frank Sinatra, Gene Kelly, Ann Miller, and Vera Ellen.  It also Betty Garrett, who was a regular on Gary Marshall's "Laverne and Shirley." This movie is directed by Gene Kelly and the costumes and dancing alone are worth a viewing. 
  • "How to Marry a Millionaire (1953): Lauren Bacall, Betty Grable, and Marilyn Monroe and featuring William Powell (of "Thin Man" fame).  Three of the hottest women in the history of film, having fun together and finding love in the big city.  
  • "Best In Show" (2000): A list of great star ensemble casts wouldn't be complete without a Christopher Guest movie featuring his wonderful group in this semi-improvised satire of the world of championship dog breeding.  Michael McKean (also from "Laverne and Shirley!" Take that, Gary!) Eugene Levy, Catherine O'Hara, Jennifer Coolidge, Jane Lynch, and Parker Posey all join Guest in this hilarious dog-centric mockumentary.  
  • "Moonstruck" (1987): Yes, it centers on Cher, but the ensemble cast, including Nicolas Cage, Olympia Dukakis, Danny Aiello, John Mahoney, and Vincent Gardenia all conspire to treat us to some of the true magic New York has to offer. And, it takes place around the holidays!    

About this column: Leslie Combemale, "Cinema Siren," is a movie lover and aficionado in Northern Virginia. Alongside Michael Barry, she owns ArtInsights, an animation and film art gallery in Reston Town Center. She has a background in film and art history. She often is invited to present at conventions such as the San Diego Comic Con, where she has been a panelist for The Art of the Hollywood Movie Poster and the Harry Potter Fandom discussion. See more of her reviews and interviews on www.artinsightsmagazine.com.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »