patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

SPEAK OUT: Should Teachers Be Armed?

In interview on WTOP Tuesday, Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell says idea should be explored.

 

Gov. Bob McDonnell said on Tuesday that it may be time to explore the idea of arming teachers and other school officials.

The Republican governor made his remarks in an interview Tuesday on WTOP. His remarks came during a discussion of the killing of 20 children and six adults at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newton, Conn., on Friday.

The governor was asked: "What about the idea of allowing people — adults, supervisors, principals, teachers — to be armed inside the public schools of Virginia?"

"I know there's been a knee-jerk reaction against that," McDonnell said. "I think there should at least be a discussion about it."

"If people were armed, not just a police officer but other officials who were trained and chose to have a weapon, certainly there would have been an opportunity to stop aggressors from coming into a school."

"So I think that's a reasonable discussion that ought to be had," he said. "The key is don't overreact — really get to the bottom of what works and what can make a difference."

"If a person like that [principal in Connecticut] was armed and trained, could they have stopped the carnage in the classroom? Perhaps."

Do you agree with the governor? Tell us in the comments.

Related Topics: Gov. Bob McDonnell

Rev. Charles Oberkehr

7:34 am on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Hopefully Gov McDonnell has sobered up by now. Or, maybe today he'll want to discuss giving all VA elementary school students Kevlar school uniforms. There is one, long overdue discussion that needs to happen. We need sensible gun policy. We don't need to waste any more time with politician's inane, self-serving avoidance tactics.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Deacon Douglas

8:41 am on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Oh sure, padre--and if some nut breaks into your congregation some Sunday morning and starts blowing away the parishioners, what are you going to do . . . . huddle up and pray for safety? You're the one who's been into the communion wine, I'm afraid. You and your liberal following better get real about self-protection or face the ultimate consequences!

Martin Tillett

8:19 am on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Time for the Governor to go piss up a rope. Does this guy seriously think he is a future Presidential contender? At best he might have a future as a television media news reader since when expressing his own genuine thoughts he only manages to hang himself over and over again. Thank goodness he is limited to one term as Governor in Virginia.

Reply

Bill Zaccagnino

9:11 am on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

I could not believe the governor would say this. How many children will be killed in the crossfire? How many children will be killed by a teacher's gun mistakenly placed within reach of the class? How many children will be killed by a mistaken perception of danger by a teacher? Don't we have enough insanity in Virginia's gun laws? Didn't the legislature and the governor do enough by opening the floodgates of the gun laws earlier this year? Maybe the governor should actually take his self-proclaimed title "pro-life" and actually recognize that gun control is a pro-life issue: http://americamagazine.org/content/all-things/gun-control-pro-life-issue.

Reply
Comment_arrow

April Crews

9:40 am on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

I agree with Mr. Zaccagnino. Guns should not be within reach of students. This is a crazy idea. The only one that would be even slightly considerable to me would be giving teachers taser guns. But even those could accidentally get in the hands of children too. What schools need is better security with metal detectors. If there were metal detectors that went off like a fire alarm when a gun came into a school, that would be a better idea.

Middledaughter

12:15 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

This is getting ridiculous!!! As a former teacher, there is no way I would have wanted to work in a building, knowing that anyone in the administration was armed.

I ask the governor, why not consider working with the federal government to find ways to get assault weapons, etc. out of the hands of people who intend to ,misuse them? Why not work on bringing our mental health system into the 21st century? Last but not least, why not remember the adage, if you don't know what to say, don't say anything?

Reply

jim andrews

12:15 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Interesting that the gun community believes that more guns will keep us safe...using that logic, I guess we should be the safest nation in the world.

Reply

Peter Karalus

12:25 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Believe a valid idea to explore, one well trained teacher, such as we have in airplanes , ( Pilot, Crew .? ), and other places , could possibly stop such horrible actions. The police can never get there in time to stop the massacre until too late, and once they arrive the sicko kills himself . When faced with an armed teacher, or guard, might kill himself sooner..?/ Best solution, stop these very ill people from even getting there, they usually leave signs of their pending breakdown. much earlier Guns have nothing to do with it.... Maybe we should consider banning auto's also..??..kill about 40,000 a year on our highways..???

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bill Zaccagnino

1:55 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Peter--The number of vehicle fatalities is actually more like 30,000 now...still a horrendous number. But the reason for the drop is because auto manufacturers have had to put numerous safety devices into vehicles: safety belts, airbags (front and side), collapsing steering wheels, crumple zones in the frames of cars, and other features. Parents and other drivers with children in the car must use child safety seats. Drivers must be licensed, indicating knowledge and skills. Cars must be registered and inspected annually. All of these things are dictated by laws and regulations. We use the word "crash" instead of "accident" now in recognition of the inherent human error in every instance. The same potential for human error exists with every gun. One big difference, though is that vehicles are built with the primary purpose of transportation. Guns, on the other hand, are built with the primary purpose of delivering deadly force. McDonnell's idea is absurd; do we really want to raise generations of children who believe guns should be part of everyday life? Aren't 30,000 gun shot deaths a year enough?

jim andrews

12:41 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

It wouldn't bother me to have police officers assigned to schools...they are professionals. A trained teacher would probably due more harm than good. Comparing an instrument that has only one purpose, that is, to kill (and you to clay pigeons) to transportation accidents? Really? Way too much NRA literature being read. I'm not against having guns to protect one's residence..but anyone who doesn't think we've gone way overboard w/automatic rifles and armor piercing bullets is drinking way too much kool-aid.

Reply

Janine Kovack

1:12 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

YES I AGREE! with Gov. Bob McDonnell "Gun free" zones "invite" bad guys! THINK!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bill Zaccagnino

4:14 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Janine--Seriously? You really think "gun-free zones" at schools draw the bad guys? If that were the case, we'd have shootings at schools everyday. Frankly, a suicidal person intent on shooting up a school won't even notice the "gun-free zone" signs and won't care if he sees them.

Dee Harwood

3:08 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

How about Federal School Marshalls? Take the survey now: http://lnkd.in/V8qtVV

Reply
Comment_arrow

jim andrews

4:42 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Not a bad idea...I bet someone brings up the defecit though.

Ed Mortimer

4:22 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

If you think bringing guns into our Virginia schools are going to make our schools safer, we might as well live in China where Government controls everything. Our hearts and prayers go out to all affected by the Sandy Hook shooting, but lets not over react to one horrific incident. Our kids are in the safest schools anywhere in the world, but part of the price of freedom is we cant prevent every sick individual attack. Instead of bringing guns to our schools, lets walk our kids to school, lets offer support to teachers and staff and watch what is going on in our own communities.

Reply

Steve Chaconas

4:28 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Schools are easy targets. Violence occurs? Call the police...the guys with guns. A properly trained gun carrier in the school will deter and defend. The theater in Colorado where Giffords was shot was the only one in the area that banned (with a sign) conceal carry...chance or choice for the gunman? Even the "hated" NRA decal deters criminals!

Reply

Barbara

4:56 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

My daughter was raised in Mt. Vernon and became a teacher and lives in Maryland.
I always wished she could return to Virginia until today. Now I am grateful that she lives in a state where the Governor understands that arming teachers is not a good idea. I cannot imagine why our Governor thinks this is a good idea and hope he realizes many of his constituents are not in favor of his suggestin.

Reply

Jody

6:15 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

McDonnell wasn't proposing anything. He said it was something that could be included in discussions and it should be. This response gets to the heart of the concern (the safety of our children in schools) more than calling for more gun control laws and could possibly save lives if someone goes beserk in school with any kind of weapon. You can't stop crazy people from doing crazy things; you can only try to add as much protection as is feasible. In our messed up modern world we have armed security on planes, at concerts, high schools, stores, malls, and just about everywhere. I don't think this is such a far-out idea; it's just a shame that our society has fallen to this level. How about a ban on realistic-violence video games? How about a ban on CSI and violent movies and TV shows that are desensitizing our young people to the horrors of death and violence?

Reply

J. Griffin Crump

10:46 pm on Wednesday, December 19, 2012

In answer to a question, the Governor said the idea should be considered. A lot of things should be considered. In his sermon at Good Shepherd Church last Sunday, our pastor asked us to think about the presents we'll be giving our children and grandchildren for Christmas, and to consider carefully those which involve violence. My mind went immediately to any number of video games in which the taking of human or "alien" life is the measure of success. And then I thought of Hollywood and TV. If our children are fed a steady diet of violence, are the odds increased that some of them will act it out in their own lives? And to what extent has our entire culture been changing to mirror what is served up to us daily by the "infotainment" industry? This isn't a new question, of course. And we've heard for years that industry's answer: "We're only giving them what they want!"

Is it really what we want?

Reply

Leave a comment